Yes, last week we had the all-out nail biting drama of watching a kid almost become the first 9 year old ever to win the National Spelling Bee (he came in third) as a show of truly great competition (never watched the Bee on ESPN? You don't know what you are missing).
Yes, we have Showtime's Out of Order to keep us grounded in truly good writing (lots of sex, lots of angst -- Thirtysomething on cable).
Hell, we even had the Martha Stewart Movie to remind us that any one who gets in the way of our rise to the top should be stepped on while we smile and serve turkey cutlets rubbed with olive oil and sage at a table we made ourselves with old barn wood and twenty-five paint techniques.
But as the networks end their seasons and summer approaches, reality shows begin to rain down on our heads like so much acid rain...
Fame:
Debbie Allen = good TV. How can you not love the woman? "You want fame? Well, fame costs. And right here is where you start paying. IN SWEAT." I get the shivers just writing those words. My hips start shaking, my booty dances and, Debbie, I AM PAYING!
That said...
Hopeful singer/dancers jumping around on stage = bad TV. Their group performance was mediocre. Their dancing was lame. Their individual performances had me running around the room, shrieking in pain and outrage.
How badly does this show wish it were AI? It just shows that you can't copy brilliance. AI has the perfect blend of homespun excitement, talented voices, attitudinal judges and cheesey group songs. Fame has...Debbie Allen. And that's it. These kids should be singing show tunes, should be shooting for Broadway -- that would have distinguished the show from AI in a big way and made it...well, more like Fame. Instead, I had to watch some of the most painful singing EVER along with the most mushy judges EVER. And don't even get me started on Joey Fatone.
NBC, make it stop.
For Love or Money:
Right up there with Joe Millionaire in terms of evil, nasty, how-low-can-you-go TV. Fifteen women show up looking to win a guy (a la The Bachelor) and then find out that whoever wins the guy also wins $1 million. And the guy can never know about the money. A MUCH juicier premise than both The Bachelor (exactly why would you be so dumb as to compete on national TV for a boyfriend?) and Joe Millionaire (so you ARE dumb enough to compete for a boyfriend on national TV but it's okay because he's rich...oops, you were ALSO dumb enough to believe the producers when they told you the guy was rich!). Here, at least the women have their minds on their money (and their money on their minds) knowing they will get a check if they get the guy. But, oh, their minds...let's just say they aren't the shiniest stars in the sky. Note this exchange between two contestants:
Girl 1 (looking around the lounge in the beautiful Bel Air mansion where they will live): I can just see me, curled up with a book in here.
Girl 2 (eyes wide): Do you read?
Girl 1 (laughing): NO.
I was so scared for the future of our country at that moment.
America's Next Top Model:
Truly the best of the bunch thus far. Why? There's no singing. No dancing. No boys to fight over. What it has is Elyse. Yes, there are 11 other girls but Elyse is what the show is really all about. Elyse is a six foot tall, 114 pound goddess who also happens to be a med school student and very, very intelligent. In the real world, Elyse struggles with being an Amazon. In the world of ANTM, Elyse struggles with being smart in a penthouse full of girls who may or may not be able to sound out the words in a Dr. Seuss book. This, my friends, is what good TV is all about.
The girls lie around in their undies and discuss their pores for an hour. Elyse hides in a closet and screams. The girls practice their runway walks for days on end, debating walking styles with an earnestness that is chilling to anyone with an IQ. Elyse hides in a closet and rants. And the best part is...Elyse is actually the best model of the bunch. She's thinner (all the other girls hate her because they weigh 130), she's pretty in a unique way and because she does not give a damn, she's far more natural than all the others. The other model wannabes don't like this. They discuss her eating habits, rail against her skinnier frame. The fact that she's an atheist drives the three Jesus model wannabes over the edge and they begin to look upon her with a dislike that is decidedly un-Jesus. The fact that she would rather be a doctor than a model causes a near riot amongst the other girls, leaving them spitting with rage. The other model wannabes close ranks against her with a building hatred. For the first two episodes you watch as Elyse's spirit is beaten down with hair gels, group prayers and photo shoots in the freezing cold. She's existing on oatmeal and hour long rants in the confession closet. She actually turns to the camera and yells: "ELIMINATE ME!" The other model wannabes are dancing around, war paint smeared on their faces, fire in their eyes as they mount Elyse's head on a stick. It's Lord of the Flies in that penthouse.
And then, just as last week's episode was coming to a close...Elyse gets it together. A gleam in her eye, she decides that she's going to win this damn competition. No matter what. You could literally feel the power shift, hear the imaginary swell of the music. Elyse is going to kick some model booty. I LOVE THIS SHOW!
Now, this week, AI Juniors begins. I'm going to watch but I'm telling you now, ANTM is the show of the summer. A little bit of evil competition to tide you over until the next AI begins. Things are looking up...
PS: how come Ruben got a contract, Clay got a contract but my beloved K-Lo is contract-free?